> The differences I know of off the top of my head are:
> the older tapes have a 7 year retention and were
> created in early 2005. Also, the tapes ejected
> usually fall within the backup selection's 'window'
> of 0 to 5 days ago.
Does all the vault profiles for ejecting specified "0 to 5 days ago" in backup selection's 'window'? If it is, that could be the reason. i.e. The media are either Active or Full but had backup images older than 5 days. Hence they're not in the selection criteria for vault to eject.
One test you may like to perform is: On NBU Admin Console, go to Media and Device Management -> Media -> Volume Pools -> Offsite, sort the result by Last Mount column by clicking on the column title. The nearest date of these 200 tapes should be more than 5 days.
Do this test with care -> Create a test vault profile with the backup selection windows to just covers those unejected media with neartest date. Be careful of the setting, we don't want to end up ejecting 200+ tapes.
There's an example in NBU help. (Go to the Vault profile Choose Backup tab, click on Help button and select Choose Backup Configuration Options from the left plan (help content), read the description of Backup Started property.